• IRIS Center
  • COVID-19 RESOURCES
  • Resources
    • IRIS Resource Locator
      Modules, case studies, activities, & more
    • Evidence-Based Practice Summaries
      Research annotations
    • High-Leverage Practices
      IRIS resources on HLPs
    • IRIS Alignment Tools
      HLPs, SiMRs, & CEEDAR ICs
    • Films
      Portrayals of people with disabilities
    • Children's Books
      Portrayals of people with disabilities
    • For Faculty
      Sample syllabi, curriculum matrices, & more
    • For PD Providers
      Sample PD activities, planning forms, & more
    • For Independent Learners
      Resources & tools for independent learners
    • Website Navigation Videos
      Getting around our Website & modules
    • New & Coming Soon
      Latest modules & resources
    • Glossary
      Disability related terms
  • PD Options
    • PD Certificates for Educators
      Our certificate, your PD hours
    • School & District Platform
      A powerful tool for school leaders
    • Log in to Your IRIS PD
    • Micro-credentials
      Short. Focused. Intense.
  • Articles & Reports
    • Articles
      Articles about IRIS use & efficacy
    • Internal IRIS Reports
      Reports on IRIS use & accomplishments
    • External Evaluation Reports
      Evaluations of the IRIS Center
    • Learner Outcomes
      Summaries of module effectiveness
    • Consumer Satisfaction
      Feedback and testimonials from IRIS users
    • IRIS Stories
      Our resources, your stories
    • News & Events
      What, when, & where it's happening
  • About
    • Who We Are
      Our team, experts, & advisors
    • What We Do
      Our resources & process
    • Contact Us
      Get in touch with IRIS
  • Help
    • Help & Support
      Get the full benefit from our resources
    • Website Navigation Videos
      Getting around our Website & modules
  • AAA
  • Module
  • Challenge
  • Initial Thoughts
  • Perspectives & Resources
  • Wrap Up
  • Assessment
Challenge
Initial Thoughts
Perspectives & Resources

Why do so many adolescents struggle with content-area reading?

  • Page 1: Middle School Literacy
  • Page 2: Text Complexity

What can teachers do to help students develop stronger vocabulary knowledge?

  • Page 3: Vocabulary Knowledge
  • Page 4: Introduction to Possible Sentences
  • Page 5: Select Words
  • Page 6: Pronounce and Define Words
  • Page 7: Compose Possible Sentences
  • Page 8: Read Text and Revise Sentences

What can teachers do to improve students’ comprehension of content-area text?

  • Page 9: Comprehending Content-Area Text
  • Page 10: Introduction to Anticipation-Reaction Guide
  • Page 11: Identify Personal Perspectives
  • Page 12: Document Evidence and Consider Perspectives
  • Page 13: Modify or Qualify Perspectives

Resources

  • Page 14: References & Additional Resources
  • Page 15: Credits
Wrap Up
Assessment
We want to hear from you. Please complete our brief Module Feedback Form.

What can teachers do to improve students’ comprehension of content-area text?

Page 9: Comprehending Content-Area Text

In addition to vocabulary knowledge, understanding content-area text requires strong reading comprehension. Reading comprehension comprises many different skills, including the ability to cite textual evidence and to consider multiple perspectives. When students combine a reliance on textual evidence and an awareness of perspective taking, they gain a deeper understanding of a text passage than when they simply focus on general impressions or surface-level facts. In fact, students must learn to use evidence from what they’ve read to analyze the alignment of their personal perspectives with those of one or more authors. Let’s explore the importance of both textual evidence and perspective-taking in more depth.

Textual Evidence

old documentsStandards for college and career readiness emphasize text-dependent analysis. Such analysis requires students to rely on the information they read rather than on their personal experiences or prior knowledge. An example of this expectation is Anchor Standard 1 from the Common Core State Standards for Reading:

x

text-dependent analysis

The process of gaining a thorough understanding of information, details, concepts, and perspectives through a careful reading of text

Read closely to determine what the text says explicitly and to make logical inferences from it; cite specific textual evidence when writing or speaking to support conclusions drawn from the text.

Students who can answer questions, write, or talk about a text without using textual evidence have less motivation to try and comprehend that text. For example, compare the two assignments below

Assignment A

After reading the passage on global climate change in your textbook, answer the following questions:

  1. List 1–2 extreme weather events that have affected our community over the last five years.
  2. Do you think these events were caused by global climate change?
  3. How did you feel about the ways in which these events affected our community?
  4. What suggestions do you have to prepare for future events like these?

Assignment B

After reading the passage on global climate change in your textbook, answer the following questions:

  1. Compare the methods of global climate change detection that used oceanographic, glacial, and varves analyses in the early twentieth century. Include the major findings of each as well as methodological weaknesses.
  2. Describe how changes to these methodologies in the late twentieth century affected theories of global climate change.
  3. Your text states, “Even with the best scientific data available, people see only what they believe to be true.” Do you agree with this statement? Justify your response, citing information from the passage.

Although the questions from Assignment A might tap into students’ prior knowledge—something that does support comprehension—students would not have to cite textual evidence from the passage in order to complete the assignment. Students’ responses might demonstrate creativity, but even an especially creative and well-articulated response could be crafted with little basis in the curricular materials about climate change. In contrast, they would need to not only read but also to understand and be able to cite from the passage to answer the questions from Assignment B.

Perspective-Taking

Image of Abraham Lincoln and Frederick Douglass Both the reader’s and author’s perspectives influence reading comprehension. Whereas opinion responses rely heavily on one perspective—the student’s—it is just as important for skilled readers to consider alternative perspectives. As students advance through the middle grades, college and career readiness standards reflect a progression in skills associated with perspective-taking. As can be seen in the Common Core State Standards for Reading: Informational Text, student should be able to:

  • Grade 6: Compare and contrast one author’s presentation of events with that of another (e.g., a memoir written by and a biography on the same person).
  • Grade 7: Analyze how two or more authors writing about the same topic shape their presentations of key information by emphasizing different evidence or advancing different interpretations of facts.
  • Grade 8: Analyze a case in which two or more texts provide conflicting information on the same topic and identify where the texts disagree on matters of fact or interpretation.

Research Shows

  • Teaching students to analyze historical evidence and perspective has been found to improve both their advanced literacy skills and understanding of history.
    (Kucer, 2010)
  • Awareness of the source of scientific information or of the narrator of a story is related to students’ comprehension of informational science texts and narrative prose, respectively.
    (Kucer, 2010)

On the next pages, you will learn a structured approach to citing textual evidence and examining the reader’s and author’s perspectives—the Anticipation-Reaction Guide.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
Back Next
1...89101112131415
Join Our E-Newsletter Sign Up
  • Home
  • About IRIS
  • Our Values
  • Sitemap
  • Web Accessibility
  • Glossary
  • Terms of Use
  • Contact Us
Join Our E-Newsletter Sign Up

The IRIS Center Peabody College Vanderbilt University Nashville, TN 37203 iris@vanderbilt.edu. The IRIS Center is funded through a cooperative agreement with the U.S. Department of Education, Office of Special Education Programs (OSEP) Grant #H325E170001. The contents of this Website do not necessarily represent the policy of the U.S. Department of Education, and you should not assume endorsement by the Federal Government. Project Officer, Sarah Allen.

Copyright 2021 Vanderbilt University. All rights reserved.

* For refund and privacy policy information visit our Help & Support page.

Creative Commons License This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

  • Vanderbilt Peabody College