• IRIS Center
Careers at IRIS
Donate to IRIS
  • Resources
    • IRIS Resource Locator
      Modules, case studies, activities, & more
    • Evidence-Based Practice Summaries
      Research annotations
    • High-Leverage Practices
      IRIS resources on HLPs
    • Films
      Portrayals of people with disabilities
    • Children's Books
      Portrayals of people with disabilities
    • For Faculty
      Top tips, coursework planning, & more
    • For PD Providers
      Sample PD activities, planning forms, & more
    • Website Navigation Videos
      Getting around our Website & modules
    • New & Coming Soon
      Latest modules & resources
    • Glossary
      Disability related terms
    • IRIS Archived Resources
      Modules, alignment tools, & more
  • PD Options
    • PD Certificates for Educators
      Our certificate, your PD hours
    • Log in to Your IRIS PD
    • For PD Providers
      Sample PD activities, planning forms, & more
    • IRIS+ School & District Platform
      A powerful tool for school leaders
  • Articles & Reports
    • Articles
      Articles about IRIS use & efficacy
    • Internal IRIS Reports
      Reports on IRIS use & accomplishments
    • External Evaluation Reports
      Evaluations of the IRIS Center
    • Learner Outcomes
      Summaries of module effectiveness
    • IRIS Stories
      Our resources, your stories
    • News & Events
      What, when, & where it's happening
  • About
    • Who We Are
      Our team, experts, & advisors
    • What We Do
      Our resources & process
    • Contact Us
      Get in touch with IRIS
  • Help
    • Help & Support
      Get the full benefit from our resources
    • Website Navigation Videos
      Getting around our Website & modules
  • Module
  • Challenge
  • Initial Thoughts
  • Perspectives & Resources
  • Wrap Up
  • Assessment
Challenge
Initial Thoughts
Perspectives & Resources

Do these learning experiences sound familiar? Do you think they are effective? (Opinion Question: No Resources)

How can educators design instruction that engages and challenges all students?

  • Page 1: Universal Design for Learning
  • Page 2: Addressing Barriers
  • Page 3: UDL Principles

How can educators identify and address potential barriers when designing instruction?

  • Page 4: Goals
  • Page 5: Assessments
  • Page 6: Methods
  • Page 7: Materials
  • Page 8: Designing with UDL

Resources

  • Page 9: References & Additional Resources
  • Page 10: Credits
Wrap Up
Assessment
We want to hear from you. Please complete our brief Module Feedback Form.

How can educators identify and address potential barriers when designing instruction?

Page 7: Materials

student writing in notebook at deskJust as educators implement many different instructional methods, they also use a wide variety of instructional materials to represent the content. Often, these materials include books and other forms of printed text, lectures, videos, graphics, and worksheets. These formats are typically fixed or static, meaning the media cannot be manipulated or changed in any way. Many students are not engaged or challenged by fixed materials, while others may not be able to access them at all.

Did You Know?

You can try out some features of digital text right here in this module. Click on the blue accessibility icon at the bottom right of the page to adjust the content, color, and orientation of this page.

When instructional materials are not accessible, they become a barrier to some students’ learning. Educators who design with UDL in mind select and create flexible, rather than fixed, materials. The most common type of flexible media is digital text. When text is presented digitally on a computer or other device, the content can be manipulated in different ways. For instance, the user may be able to increase the font size, use a text-to-speech feature to have the text read aloud, or change the colors or contrast on the page. Digital tools also make it easier to embed other information to support comprehension (e.g., glossaries, graphics, animations, hyperlinks).

For Your Information

The Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) outline an international standard for accessibility of web-based materials. The WCAG standards reflect four principles, which can be remembered using the acronym POUR:

Perceivable: All learners can see, hear, and/or touch the information.

Operable: All learners can navigate the information independently using their preferred tools.

Understandable: All learners can understand the information as a result of clear and predictable design.

Robust: All learners can access the information on a range of current and future technologies, including assistive technologies.

Materials are not automatically accessible just because they are digital. Some simple ways educators can improve the accessibility of digital materials are to:

  • Use online tools that generate captions for videos
  • Add alt text to images in documents and slides
    x

    alt text

    A written description of a digital image that is read aloud by screen reader software and displays on the page if the image fails to load.

  • Format documents using built-in headings and styles to support navigation for those using screen reader software
    x

    screen reader software

    Any of a variety of computer programs or applications that enable a computer to convey information through non-visual means (e.g., text-to-speech, braille); a type of assistive technology commonly used by individuals who are blind, but also by those with low vision and learning disabilities.

  • Use descriptive and meaningful text for hyperlinks rather than “click here” or “learn more”
  • Ensure high contrast between text and background colors (e.g., black text on white background)
  • Run accessibility checkers when available in software programs

For more information about accessible educational materials, view the following resources created by CAST’s National Center on Accessible Educational Materials.

logo for Accessible Educational Materials

  • Designing for Accessibility
  • Procuring Accessible Digital Materials and Technologies for Teaching and Learning: The What, Why, Who, and How

CAST logo

Tips for Accessible Educational Materials

In this interview, Kelli Suding explains how materials and technology must work together to make instruction accessible for all students.

Kelli Suding

Kelli Suding, MEd
Technical Assistance Specialist

CAST | National Center on AEM

(time: 2:13)

/wp-content/uploads/module_media/udl_media/audio/UDL_p07_suding.mp3

View Transcript

Transcript: Kelli Suding, MEd

Digital does not mean accessible. It just means it’s available for our learners. Let’s talk about what accessibility in general means. So accessibility is meaning a person with a disability can acquire the same information, can engage in the same interactions, and enjoy the same services as a person without a disability in an equally effective, equally integrated manner with substantially equivalent ease of use. So you notice that we’re talking about “same”—acquire the same information, same interactions, same services. And we think about that with our materials that we’re giving our students, accessible education materials or A-E-M. AEM allows us to make those into accessible formats. So it’s providing that same information but in a different format, so all of our learners can access the information independently. So the materials that we’re giving our students must be accessible. The technology has to be accessible, as well. And then the assistive technology has to work with all of those. If our instruction is not created in a way that we can change those formats or students can change those formats where they access that text, it’s not going to work. So when AEM works, the materials, the technology, and the assistive technology all have to work together. So it’s just not one part when it comes to accessibility in accessing our instruction. When we’re giving our learners materials, we have to think about how we’re designing and keeping the principles of POUR. It is an acronym, POUR, that’s going to guide you in building materials. And it also is a great way to get guiding questions, so then you can also vet your own materials, or when you’re looking at other things, you can ask questions about vetting other materials that you may give to our students. The P being perceivable, asking yourself, can everyone sense the content in multiple ways? The O is for operable. Can everyone navigate the content and interact in multiple ways? And then the U is understandable. Is the content presented in a way that’s intuitive? Is it predictable? And then the R is robust. Is it compatible with the technologies, including those assistive technologies? So again, the materials, the technology, and the assistive technology all have to work together.

In addition to using static materials, educators unfamiliar with UDL often use a single modality to present information. For instance, they may provide only a printed textbook during a lesson. This could create a barrier because it assumes that all learners can read and comprehend on grade level and in English, see the text, or physically hold the book. Educators committed to UDL present content in accessible, flexible, and multiple formats. Furthermore, they consider ways to use a variety of materials, both physical and digital, to support student learning. Educators may accomplish this in many ways, such as:

  • Providing technology tools (e.g., calculators, audiobooks) to help students engage with and navigate learning materials
  • Using graphic organizers to activate prior knowledge or as note-taking tools to guide students’ information processing
  • Designing presentation slides with graphics and short bullet points to help students recognize key elements of the content
  • Using physical models or demonstrations to help students visualize concepts or processes

It is also important to remember that barriers can exist not only in the format but also in the content of materials. Educators should take care to provide material options that reflect and connect to students’ diverse backgrounds and lived experiences. In this interview, Shauntā Singer discusses how culturally responsive materials can help students engage in and make meaning of content.

Shauntā Singer

Shauntā Singer, PhD
Research & Development/
Professional Learning Research Scientist

CAST

(time: 2:07)

/wp-content/uploads/module_media/udl_media/audio/UDL_p07_singer.mp3

View Transcript

Transcript: Shauntā Singer, PhD

Oftentimes we think about barriers existing in instructional material themselves. But to take it a step further, a lot of times there are barriers that exist within the content of instruction. Oftentimes barriers in the content exist because students are unable to see themselves in the actual content. So one barrier to engagement is that if I am not interested or the content is not relevant to me, I’m no longer engaged or I have little engagement. So the barrier to the content of the material is the lack of cultural relevancy. The other barrier that exists oftentimes is in the perspectives that we have in the content that we use. So a very traditional perspective can be literature that we choose to teach certain concepts. And so a barrier becomes, “How do I see myself in that content?” A barrier becomes teachers only using certain content that is personal to them but may not be meaningful to the students that they’re teaching. Another barrier could be the perspectives of content that is given to students as they learn. So I like to think of multiple means of representation as looking at various perspectives that can also be brought in through our curriculum. We tend to have a very Western way of looking at things, but there are other perspectives, both globally, internationally, that students should be engaged in. And so a way to vary the content is to bring in these diverse perspectives because the barrier, remember, is relevancy. So if you think about students whose families and cultures or values may not be represented in the way we teach here in Northern America and then the relevance is limited. And so the barriers are still in existence.

Flexible materials align with all three UDL principles. Educators provide:

  • Multiple means of engagement by offering choice of materials to encourage student autonomy and varied levels of challenge
  • Multiple means of representation by offering alternatives to solely visual or auditory materials and by illustrating content through multiple forms of media
  • Multiple means of action and expression by ensuring access to varied tools and technologies for navigation, composition, and communication

Furthermore, educators can strengthen students’ agency by empowering them with the skills to choose the best materials for their own learning.

Keep in Mind

As educators select or create instructional materials using a UDL lens, they can ask themselves the following questions:

  • How will I provide flexible materials that support the learning goal?
  • Have I verified the accessibility of all digital materials?
  • In what ways are the materials personally and culturally relevant for learners?
  • How will I encourage learners to reflect on how different tools, materials, and resources support their learning?

These questions have been adapted from the following handout.

CAST logo

Top 5 UDL Tips for Learning Environments

Activity

Now that Mr. Hughes, Ms. Tong, and Mrs. Rios understand the role of accessibility and flexibility in UDL, each educator realizes that they have been using fixed materials that do not meet the needs of variable learners. Below, consider how you would address the barriers in their materials and then discover how the educators intend to do so.


mister hughes
Mr. Hughes

Elementary mathematics lesson goal:

Students will represent numerical data on a bar graph and use the graph to answer questions.

Help Mr. Hughes address the barriers in his materials.

Take a look at the materials previously used in this lesson:

  • Interactive whiteboard for teacher modeling
  • Standard graph paper
  • Physical worksheets

Reflect on the following:

  1. What potential barriers do you recognize in these materials?
  2. How can Mr. Hughes revise his materials to be more universally designed?

You may choose to reflect on these questions in a variety of ways, such as jotting down some notes, drawing a picture, or discussing with your colleagues. The fields below are available as options to record your thoughts.

Note: These fields are provided for reflection purposes only; your answers will not be available for downloading or printing.

Enter text here

Draw here using your cursor or finger

| Line width :| Color :

mister hughes

After you have generated your own ideas, learn how Mr. Hughes intends to address the barriers in his materials (time: 0:39).

/wp-content/uploads/module_media/udl_media/audio/udl_hughes_p07.mp3

View Transcript

Transcript: Mr. Hughes

As I’ve thought about my assessments and methods, I’ve already started to identify some challenges to the materials. During small group work, instead of just giving them standard graph paper, I should make sure students have choices of things like different-sized graph paper, different physical tools like colored pencils or markers or crayons, and even digital graphing options. Last year I had a student with fine motor challenges who had an individual accommodation to make her graphs on the computer. There’s no reason other students couldn’t do that too. The worksheets also aren’t flexible at all, so I could provide different options for them to answer questions, like on mini whiteboards or on their devices.


ms tong
Ms. Tong

Middle school language arts unit goal:

Students will be able to identify a theme in a grade-level piece of fiction and locate supporting details in the text.

Help Ms. Tong address the barriers in her materials.

Take a look at the materials previously used in this unit:

  • Paperback copy of the novel
  • Shared online document on each student’s own digital device
  • Shared online document projected onto the classroom screen
  • Paper and pencil or keyboard for composing the essay

Reflect on the following:

  1. What potential barriers do you recognize in these materials?
  2. How can Ms. Tong revise her materials to be more universally designed?

You may choose to reflect on these questions in a variety of ways, such as jotting down some notes, drawing a picture, or discussing with your colleagues. The fields below are available as options to record your thoughts.

Note: These fields are provided for reflection purposes only; your answers will not be available for downloading or printing.

Enter text here

Draw here using your cursor or finger

| Line width :| Color :

ms tong

After you have generated your own ideas, learn how Ms. Tong intends to address the barriers in her methods (time: 1:18).

/wp-content/uploads/module_media/udl_media/audio/udl_tong_p07.mp3

View Transcript

Transcript: Ms. Tong

I’ve always used a class set of paperbacks for this unit, but that really has no options for customizing the color, the size, or the spacing of the text. A digital version of the novel could allow for that, and I wouldn’t have to get a separate large-print version for my student with low vision. Students could also listen to an audiobook—my goal is comprehension, not word recognition or fluency. Some of the vocabulary in the book might also be a barrier to students’ understanding, so they might benefit from a glossary or even hyperlinked definitions in a digital book. I’ve also seen the essay materials become a roadblock for some students. I started allowing them to type instead of handwrite if they choose, but even that can be challenging. I could offer options like recording their essay or using speech-to-text to dictate their ideas, too. I think the shared document is pretty accessible since it’s digital, but I should probably run the accessibility checker just to make sure. They also need a device and internet access at home to contribute to the document, so I might need to think about different ways they could share their ideas if access to technology is a barrier.


mrs. rios
Mrs. Rios

High school biology lesson goal:

Students will be able to model and explain the process of mitosis.

Help Ms. Rios address the barriers in her materials.

Take a look at the materials previously used in this lesson:

  • Oral lecture with supplemental text-based slides
  • Textbook chapter
  • Physical science notebook

Reflect on the following:

  1. What potential barriers do you recognize in these materials?
  2. How can Mrs. Rios revise her materials to be more universally designed?

You may choose to reflect on these questions in a variety of ways, such as jotting down some notes, drawing a picture, or discussing with your colleagues. The fields below are available as options to record your thoughts.

Note: These fields are provided for reflection purposes only; your answers will not be available for downloading or printing.

Enter text here

Draw here using your cursor or finger

| Line width :| Color :

mrs. rios

After you have generated your own ideas, learn how Mrs. Rios intends to address the barriers in her assessments (time: 0:53).

/wp-content/uploads/module_media/udl_media/audio/udl_rios_p07.mp3

View Transcript

Transcript: Ms. Rios

I almost always use slides to present the content, but right now they are just full of the same words that I say in the lecture. I should think about reducing the text on the slides to highlight the big ideas and add more pictures and diagrams in to clarify the more abstract concepts. And this year, I have a student who is deaf—I’m sure visual aids will help him, but I’ll still need to make sure that his ASL interpreter is always visible. And, just like in the past, the textbook chapter has caused some barriers because of its reading level, and it’s definitely a fixed format. In addition to the textbook, I could offer some other options for learning about mitosis. I know there are some great online videos, articles, and even simulations that I could add in. I’ve also been thinking about how to give students more choices for note-taking. I could maybe create some different templates or even provide a digital format of the science notebook.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
Back Next
12345678910
Join Our E-Newsletter Sign Up
  • Home
  • About IRIS
  • Our Values
  • Sitemap
  • Web Accessibility
  • Glossary
  • Terms of Use
  • Contact Us
Join Our E-Newsletter Sign Up

The IRIS Center Peabody College Vanderbilt University Nashville, TN 37203 [email protected]. The IRIS Center is funded through a cooperative agreement with the U.S. Department of Education, Office of Special Education Programs (OSEP) Grant #H325E220001. The contents of this Website do not necessarily represent the policy of the U.S. Department of Education, and you should not assume endorsement by the Federal Government. Project Officer, Sarah Allen.

Copyright 2023 Vanderbilt University. All rights reserved.

* For refund and privacy policy information visit our Help & Support page.

Creative Commons License This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

  • Vanderbilt Peabody College